Perhaps you are not aware that it is possible to watch a show on television where two brothers cruise the United States in a black 1967 Impala, killing demons and taking their emotions seriously in the way only people under 30 can.   But there is such a show, and I am pretty sure the Brothers Winchester (for that is Sam and Dean’s un-ironic surname) would agree that this doll case in Appleton, Wisconsin is one of the creepiest things they have every seen.